This 3-way baked potato recipe will allow you a ton of flexibility. While the methods differ, they will give you perfectly baked, tender potatoes. You can bake them in foil, finish them off with a crispy layer, or bake them without any covering at all.
- The lower the temperature is, the longer the item will take to completely cook. - The smaller pieces will bake for a much shorter time than whole potatoes or even wedges.
On average, it will take between 20-30 minutes to make medium-sized baked potatoes at 375.
If you want to keep your foil-baked potatoes crispy, remove the covering during the final 10 minutes of baking.
Potatoes are fully baked when their internal temperature has reached between 208-211ºF (97.8-99.4ºC).